Filter by Category:
Reader's Workshop Management
Standardized Reading Assessments
Annotating & Note-Taking
Writing About Reading
Fluency & Phonics
Writer's Workshop Management
6 Traits of Writing
6 Traits Mini-lessons
Opinion / Persuasive / Argumentative
Informative / Expository / Explanatory
Narrative Writing / Poetry
PK-1 Developmental Writing Stages
Assessment & Feedback
Include All Facets of the Task
january 14, 2009
When announcing a larger writing assignment, teachers go over each required component, verifying that all students understand the expectations. However, when the assignments are turned in, invariably there are numerous writings that lack some of the required information.
This frustration may have been avoided with a visual strategy. When initially detailing the facets of the task, identify a highlighter color to be affiliated with each one. Then, when students think they are done, they self-assess by highlighting the different facets within their own writing with the appropriate colors. (If handwriting, they can use a marker. If composing the piece on a screen, they can change the font or use a digital highlighter.)
For example, a first-grade animal report may require students to:
- Highlight the title and introduction/beginning in pink.
- Highlight sentences about the animal’s physical description in orange.
- Highlight sentences about the animal’s habitat in blue.
- Highlight sentences about the animal’s diet in yellow.
- Highlight the conclusion/ending in green.
Students use the highlighting strategy to assess whether they have included all required components for the task. For students of any age, using multi-colored highlighters just makes the revision process more fun. Of course, it must be made clear that if a student can’t highlight a particular skill or component (because it’s not included), then he should revise to add it in. Then he can highlight it before submitting it to the teacher.
Here are other ways to use highlighters for self-assessment:
Assess that all 3 required reasons are included in a persuasive essay:
- Highlight your first reason (with examples) in green.
- Highlight your second reason (with examples) in pink.
- Highlight your third reason (with examples) in yellow.
Assess the required elements within research writing:
- Highlight your thesis statement in yellow.
- Highlight each reason (topic sentence) to support your thesis in green.
- Highlight your first source/citation in pink.
- Highlight your second source/citation in orange.
- Highlight your third source/citation in blue.
Assess the required elements within content area writing, like a science lab report:
- Highlight your hypothesis in green.
- Highlight your ordered steps in blue.
- Highlight your conclusion in pink.
Assess the required figurative language elements included within a piece:
- Highlight the 3 required similes in pink.
- Highlight the 2 required metaphors in orange.
- Highlight the 2 required alliteration phrases in blue.
This strategy not only causes students to check that they are including all required elements, but it also serves as a formative assessment. It’s a great way to gauge a student’s individual level of mastery for a particular skill. In order to highlight it, he has to realize where he has intentionally applied it.