Find the Story Within the Problem

Find the Story Within the Problem

Find the Story Within the Problem

Students who are the most successful with story problems are able to construct an accurate mental representation of the story. In fact, if students don't understand the context or situation, then they cannot identify the problem to be solved. With this in mind, focus on the story before the math.

Make a connection between summarizing stories and retelling story problems. One way to accomplish this is with the popular frame Somebody, Wanted, But, So, Then.

Somebody Wanted But So Then ELA Example for Cinderella

Using this summary frame, redefine the story elements to fit the content of a math word problem.

Identify who is relevant in the situation. Initially, practice with word problems that only have one character. Then introduce more complex problems with two or more individuals.

Although many story problems don't identify a specific setting, they imply one. Based on the activity or action, students should infer where the situation is occurring. This will help them visualize what's happening and what the problem is.

Like characters in literature, individuals in a word problem are motivated by something--they want something. In math problems, this is the activity the character is engaged in. It's what he is doing or wanting to do.

There is always something the character doesn't know. He needs to figure out something. This is the character's problem (and the math problem the student needs to solve).

Somebody Wanted But So Then Math Story Problem Example

For those struggling with word problems, just spend time retelling the situation (i.e., Somebody... wanted... but...). Students can't solve the problem if they aren't able to acknowledge the story or context. Then, introduce the fourth facet.

So... is where students reveal their mathematical thinking in words. This facet is a general outline of the steps it will take for them to determine the answer. Teachers can trace a student's line of thinking and reinforce it or refine it, as needed. So... is especially important when students face multi-step math problems.

In order to "force" students to focus on the mathematical thinking (and not simply "do" the math), black out or remove any numbers in the original story problem (Magee and Flessner's numberless word-problem strategy).

With a strong grasp of the story and the problem, reveal the specific quantities. Using their step-by-step process from the So... portion, students Then show their work.

Great Teacher Comment:

From Literacy Coach Bridget Longmeier, Seymour Community School (Seymour, IN):

Today I had the opportunity to go into a 2nd and 3rd grade classroom and model the Somebody Wanted, But, So, Then strategy for math that I learned at the Smekens Literacy Retreat! I really feel like this can be game changing, especially for our EL learners because they have a hard time understanding the language of story problems.

(In the lesson, I also incorporated Flessner's numberless word problem strategy, where you take the numbers out of the problem at first to make sure students understand what is happening and what the problem is asking.)

I can't thank you enough for all the ideas we get from you! This math stuff is really going to help our students. Thanks again!

Thanks for sharing this, Bridget! For more information about this, visit Bridget's Longmeier's blog.

Kristina Smekens

Teachers feel empowered and encouraged after working with Kristina. She is an expert at developing practical ways for K-12 teachers to apply research-based literacy strategies.
Learn More About Kristina | Email Kristina

Testimonials about Kristina

“I love all of the aha moments that I have during the presentations--everything makes sense. Brilliant! Your energy and enthusiasm make your audience hang on your every word--Incredible!” Candy Kramer, principal at Sward School, Oak Lawn, IL

“Kristina totally understands how teachers think. I love how she did so much legwork for us by cross-referencing the standards." Cindy Douthett
teacher at Flint Lake Elementary School, Valparaiso, IN

“Kristina is one of the best presenters I have ever seen. She keeps you engaged every second!” Pat Parrish
teacher at New Middletown Elementary School, Corydon, IN

“Kristina is the ‘Rachael Ray’ of education. Using research, history, and relevant examples, she scaffolds the content to launch educators in the new and unexplored—very exciting!” Trace Hinesley
teacher at Riverview Middle School, Huntington, IN

"After 33 years of teaching, I still am drawn back into Kristina's workshops because they are research-based, standards-focused, and very interactive. No matter your years of experience or age of your students you teach, you will glean a lot of great teaching strategies!" Katie Cadle
teacher at Throop Elementary School, Paoli, IN